Physical Model Studies of Energy Dissipation Systems to Rehabilitate Jinnah Barrage

Zulfiqar Ali Chaudhry

Abstract


A subsidiary weir was proposed by feasibility consultants to rehabilitate and modernize Jinnah Barrage. This weir is to be constructed across the river, at a distance of about 800 ft, downstream of the barrage. Subsidiary weir location and crest level was finally fixed on the basis of a detailed physical model study. This model study was carried by Irrigation Research Institute (IRI) at their Lahore laboratory under the technical guidance of “Feasibility Consultants”. The “Detailed Design Consultants” while finalizing rehabilitation structure (either subsidiary weir or its alternative) requested IRI for another model study, which was carried out at Nandipur Research Station. It seems that the two model studies were under taken for the same project, having almost similar objectives. This paper critically reviews the judiciousness of two model studies carried out for the same project. Furthermore, the experimental results of various rehabilitation alternatives are also discussed in terms of their reliability and effectiveness.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Chaudhry. A. Z., Nasim N. H., Shakoor. A., Alternative Report to Subsidiary Weir, Rehabilitation and Modernization of Jinnah Barrage Project, Submitted to Irrigation & Power Department, Government of Punjab, April 2008.

Chaudhry. A. Z., Energy Dissipation Problems Downstream of the Jinnah Barrage. Pakistan Journal of Engineering and Applied Sciences, 2008 Vol.3, p.19- 25.

Sectional Model of Taunsa Barrage, Irrigation & Power Department, Government of the Punjab, IRR- 1172, June 2005.

Mahboob. S.I., The Kalabagh Barrage, Punjab Engineering Congress, Paper No. 251, 1942, p66.

Mahboob. S.I, Design and Construction of Kalabagh Barrage, Punjab Engineering Congress, Paper No. 34, 1943.

Appraisal Report on Safety on Jinnah Barrage, Submitted by National Development Consultants (NDC) to Irrigation & Power Department, Government of Punjab, July 2001.

Evaluation of Safety of Jinnah Headworks, Report Submitted by Associated Consulting Engineers ACE (Pvt.) Ltd to Irrigation & Power Department, Government of Punjab, June 1998.

Feasibility Report, Jinnah Barrage, Submitted by Joint Venture of Associated Consulting Engineers (ACE) to Irrigation and Power Department, May 2005.






Copyright (c) 2016 Zulfiqar Ali Chaudhry

Powered By KICS