Field Verification of Social and Environmental Issues of Selected Water Sector Projects in Punjab – Pakistan

Afaf Ayesha

Abstract


Irrigation helps in increasing the agricultural yield and the irrigation projects are carried out for the welfare of people. The importance of environment for sustainable development of irrigation projects has been realized. Environmental Impact Assessment is being increasingly used as a tool for appropriate environmental planning. In Pakistan, PEPA (Pakistan Environmental Protection Act), 1997 establishes the framework to carry out Environmental Assessment of development projects. Various national and international agencies have developed Environmental Assessment Guidelines and Checklists for systematic evaluation of environmental impacts and their mitigation. The Social and Environmental Management Unit of Punjab Irrigation and Drainage Authority developed checklist for assessment of irrigation projects in 2007. The present study was conducted on three water sector projects namely: Concrete Lining of Dhudi Minor, Improving Nikki Deg Drain System and Rehabilitation of Khanki Barrage. The field verification of social and environmental issues of the projects was carried out according to the checklist of Social and Environmental Management Unit. The most noticeable impacts which were identified include: extended canal closure, emissions and effluents, waste generation and disposal, effect on flora, public health and safety, land acquisition, and social issues. The mitigatory measures proposed: proper project scheduling to minimize the canal closure periods, waste disposal through proper planning, preparation of detailed resettlement action plans and compensation, location of labor camps away from the settlements, avoiding unnecessary cutting of trees, and deployed machinery should be in good working condition. The recommendations of the study are to review and improve the checklists through a gradual and phased process into a more comprehensive social and environmental assessment process; capacity building of all the stakeholders; collaboration between different institutions, agencies and industries for environmental friendly and sustainable development of projects.

Full Text:

PDF

References


P.B. Shirsath; Irrigation Development in India: History & Impact, http://indiairrigation.blogspot.com/2009/01/histo ry-of-irrigation-development-in_01.html 2009, accessed on 23rd September, 2011

A. Nazir and G.R. Chaudary; Irrigated Agriculture of Pakistan, (1988) 5-15

A. Haq; Case Study of the Punjab Irrigation Department, Pakistan National Program, International Irrigation Mnagement Institute, Lahiore, (1998) 3, 69-101

A. H. Azhar, and G. Nabi; Impact Assessment of Punjab Irrigation Sector Reforms Interventions, Mehran University Research Journal of Engineering & Technology, 30 (2011) 179 – 192

A. Qureshi, and A. Haq; Islamic Republic of Pakistan Country Report, Presented in JICA Training Workshop, (2003) 6-7

UNEP, United Nations Environment Program, Environmental Management tools, Nairobi, Kenya, (2003) 10-18

Pakistan Environmental Protection Act, Rules and Regulations, Environmental Protection Department (1997)

US National Environmental Policy Act, http://eia.unu.edu/wiki/index.php/United_States, (2007), accessed on 10th December 2011

C.W.Christopher; Success by A Thousand Cuts: The Use of Environmental Impact Assessment in Addressing Climate Change, Vermont Journal of Environmental Law, 9 (2008) 549 – 613

J. Hassan; The Influence of America’s National Environmental Policy Act Internationally, Regional American Studies Conference on America and the Environment, (1999) 2 – 15

R. Riffat, and D. Khan; A Review and Evaluation of the Environmental Impact Assessment Process in Pakistan, Journal of Applied Sciences in Environmental Sanitation, 1 (2006) 17 – 29

IUCN, Mapping of EIA in Pakistan: Analysis Workshop, (2010), accessed on 9th December, 2011

J. Hassan; Environmental Laws of Pakistan, Bookbiz, (2006) 15

A.S. Khan; Institutionalization of Environmental Assessment in the Public Sector- A Strategic Approach, UNEP EIA Training Resource Manual, Case Studies from Developing Countries, 37 - 44

F. Aslam; Environmental Impact Assessment, in Pakistan- Overview, Implementation and Effectiveness, (2006), www2.lwr.kth.se/Publikationer/PDF_Files/LW R_EX_06_24.PDF, accessed on 10th December, 2011

ICID, The International Commission on Irrigation and Drainage, Environmental CheckList, Compiled by Mock, J.F., and Bolton P., (1993) 1-24

FAO, Environmental Impact Assessment of Irrigation and Drainage Projects, Compiled by: Dougherty, T.C., and Hall, Food and Agriculture Organization, Rome- Italy. A. W., (1995) 1-10

ADB, Environmental Assessment Guidelines, Asian Development Bank, Manila-Philippines, (2003) 1-15

World Bank, World Bank Environmental Assessment Guidelines, Washington DC.USA, (1991) 3-20

SEMU, Social and Environmental Assessment Guidelines for Irrigation Infrastructure, Social and Environmental Management Unit-PIDA, (2007) 4-44

S. Qadar and R. D. Athar; Pakistan’s Environmental Laws and their Compliance, (2002) 269-279

PID, Lining of Dhudi Minor Project, PC-I Proforma, Faisalabad Irrigation Zone, Punjab Irrigation Department, (2007) 1-15

PID, Improvement of Nikki Deg Project, PC-I Proforma, Lahore Irrigation Zone, Punjab Irrigation Department, (2006) 1-10

NDC and NESPAK, Feasibility Study for Punjab Barrages Rehabilitation Project Phase-I, Environmental Impact Assessment for Construction of New Khanki Barrage Project, (2004) 1-23

Government of the Punjab, Punjab Irrigation Department, Environmental and Social Impact Assessment [ESIA] for Construction of New Khanki Barrage, (2011) 1:1-8:57






Copyright (c) 2016 Afaf Ayesha

Powered By KICS